Self-Publishing vs Traditional Publishing vs Hybrid

Each route can be an excellent choice depending on your goals and prioritizes in terms of creative control, royalties, and more. Let’s break down the key differences so you can move forward knowing you’ve made the right decision for you.

What Is Self-Publishing?

Self-publishing allows authors to control every aspect of their book’s production and distribution. This route has grown in popularity, thanks in large part to platforms like Amazon’s Kindle Direct Publishing (KDP), which help to simplify the publishing process.

One of the main advantages of self-publishing is the potential for higher royalties. Authors typically receive a larger percentage of the sales compared to traditional publishing contracts. Self-publishing also offers creative freedom, allowing you to have full control over your work without needing approval from your publisher. If you’re looking for complete autonomy and the ability to publish on your own terms, self-publishing might be the ideal option.

However, self-publishing requires a significant amount of effort. As an author, you’re responsible for everything from collaborating with an editor, formatter, and cover designer to publishing and marketing your book. This can be a time-consuming and sometimes overwhelming process, especially if you’re new to the industry.

What Is Traditional Publishing?

Traditional publishing involves working with a publishing house, which handles the production, distribution, and promotion of your book. To get started with traditional publishing, authors typically need to submit their manuscript to an agent for consideration. If accepted, the publisher takes over the majority of the process, including editing, cover design, printing, and distribution to major retailers and bookstores.

Traditional publishing offers the benefit of professional support. Editors, designers, and marketers bring expertise to your project, which can result in a polished and market-ready book. Your publisher will manage finding and coordinating with these professionals.

Traditional publishers often have established relationships with bookstores and other retailers, making it easier to get your book into physical stores. For authors who want to focus on writing without the stress of managing the publishing process, traditional publishing can be a great choice. There’s also a sense of prestige associated with traditional publishing, which can improve your credibility and help you get your book noticed.

But traditional publishing can be a lengthy process. Securing a deal with a publisher can take time, and it usually requires a literary agent. Authors also have less control over the final product, as publishers have the last say. Royalties from traditional publishing are typically lower than those from self-publishing.

One of the biggest issues with traditional publishing is the barrier to entrance. Competition is fierce, and the acceptance rate is quite low. That’s why I typically recommend working with a professional editor before querying to ensure your manuscript is strong enough to get noticed.

What Is Hybrid Publishing?

Hybrid publishing blends the benefits of both self-publishing and traditional publishing. In this model, authors work with a hybrid publisher that offers services like editing, design, and distribution, but without the same level of control taken by traditional publishers. Authors typically pay for some services upfront but retain a larger share of royalties than in traditional publishing.

The hybrid model can be a good fit for authors who want professional help but also want to maintain more control and ownership of their work. While you will be vetted, competition is not as steep as it is with traditional publishing.

However, hybrid publishing isn’t always the right choice for every author. Hybrid publishing can be expensive, and the level of support can vary. It’s important to do your research to ensure they’re not a vanity press in disguise and can accommodate your needs.

Last Thoughts

There’s this common misconception that marketing is only necessary for self-publishing writers. Nowadays, regardless of the route you choose, you almost always have to develop a presence as an author if you want your book to sell.

Which Option Is Right for You?

Understanding the differences among these routes can help you make the best decision for you. The key is to remain focused on your goals and be prepared to put in the work required to make your book a success.

If you have any questions or would like advice on which route to choose, you know where to find me.